Mcgonagall, id rather have the film version than snape vs. It doesnt take anyone a full minute to close a book, put that book in a back pack and walk out a door. The harry potter and the halfblood prince quotes below are all either spoken by severus snape or refer to severus snape. Muggles guide to harry pottercharactersminerva mcgonagall. Film snape has his hax cursesplitting blindshot ohko feat, and probably wins. What does the duel between snape and mcgonagall reveal. Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower, harry potter and luna lovegood both under the invisibility cloak along with minerva mcgonagall went down. Apr 04, 2010 whos better at duel between these two harry potter characters. The ousting of severus snape also improperly referred to as the sacking of severus snape was a duel between severus snape, then headmaster of hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the hogwarts heads of houses. Mcgonagall screaming at snape that he was a coward or this beautiful oneliner when snape fled the castle. Harry is desperate to find the ravenclaw horcrux, and hufflepuffs cup must still be.
We dont really see a proper duel between the two, because snape was likely pulling punches and not trying to really injure mcgonagall. Differences between harry potter and the deathly hallows. Professor mcgonagall is present, as are professor snape and professor moody. Mcgonagall, sprout and flitwick duel snape in the great hall after harry returns and informs them that snape killed dumbledore. Aug 26, 2015 master minerva mcgonagall owner minerva mcgonagall additional details mcgonagalls wand was particularly well suited to her magical abilities. This doodle page lets the kids create their own spellbook cover from scratch, with room to draw and write on the front and back. Adventure fanfiction book daughter minerva more report. About snape, i did wonder what he must have been thinking when he was being overthrown.
For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one. No booktofilm adaptation is perfect, but for a long time, harry potter fans have felt that the philosophers stone was the closest to perfect that fandom got. The character of severus snape in harry potter and the. This skill likewise may be helping him deflect the magic mcgonagall is throwing at him, though it is equally possible that mcgonagall, knowing his ability, is using occlumency, as much as she is able to, to block snape s probes. I mean, why even base the film on the book at all if that scene was going to be changed so much. In there you will find mcgonagall out matching snape true he fled to the other heads of houses arrival but jk rowling herself has said on a fan answer page. A professor at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, snape is hostile to harry due to his resemblance to his father james, who bullied snape. The chapter that made us fall in love with professor mcgonagall. Professor mcgonagall colouring page 2 activity village. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for. Also i think mcgonagall is underrated and a lot lot more powerful than she lets on. Mcgonagall then sent a orange streak of light at snape, as snape sent a blue streak.
William mcgonagall is a literary legend and one of the best known names in the printed world. The chapter that made us fall in love with professor. Albus dumbledore, severus snape, and minerva mcgonagall are some of the most powerful and wellrespected professors hogwarts has ever seen. His disjointed verse has been popularised by the goons, pythons and muppets, spike milligan, peter sellers, jk rowling, terry pratchett and philip pullman. First class, was a scottish halfblood witch, the only daughter of muggle robert mcgonagall and witch isobel ross. Rowling fought for mcgonagalls battle the mary sue.
The biogrpahy of william mcgonagall by author norman watson. The book fell into harrys hands, and that book is filled with amendments to the. The scene is where snape comes up behind the trio after their foiled attempts to tell mcgonagall and dumbledore who had gone to the ministry that the stone is going to stolen that night. And heres the thing this book, if read from cover to cover, gives an insightful and poetic narrative to victorian historical happenings from a man who lived at the time. Throughout his adult life he claimed to have been born in edinburgh, giving his year of birth variously as 1825 or 1830, but his entry in the 1841 census gives his place of birth, like his parents, as ireland. The harry potter books from severus snapes perspective.
Snape and mcgonagall by lastlabyrinth harry potter. Maggie smith in character as minerva mcgonagall from the harry potter film series, miss poni. Master minerva mcgonagall owner minerva mcgonagall additional details mcgonagalls wand was particularly well suited to her magical abilities. The book snape was a complete jerk with no care for whats right and wrong. Read the mcgonagall tongue twister from the story 99 harry potter funnies by fairytailrocks14 with 654 reads. Minerva attended hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry and was sorted into gryffindor house, but it took the sorting hat five and a half minutes to decide if she was gryffindor or ravenclaw, which made. However, they have radically different personalities and approaches to life. Seeing here going thru so much emotions is amazing. Professor minerva mcgonagalls 10 best moments in harry. He is a starring character in neil cicieregas online potter puppet pals parodies, and has a centric episode titled bothering snape. In deathly hallows part two we see them duel, but just looks like snape is only. William mcgonagalls parents, charles and margaret, were irish. Click here to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Wands made from the fir tree work very well for transfiguration, which is where mcgonagall excelled and was the class she eventually taught at hogwarts. Mcgonagall vs snape, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction. Apr 29, 2014 headmaster severus snape vs professor mcgonagall in hd. Harry potter and the deathly hallows that was not in the book. Below the fold a photo shows harry, amy and lockhart at flourish and blotts. They both become headmaster and headmistress someday, and mcgonagall is older than snape seeing as when snape was in school mcgonagall was still deputy headmistress, but snape too, is very skilled and learned from lord voldemort. Rowling, on fighting the decision to pit harry potter against severus snape in harry potter.
I noticed dumbledore and mcgonagall staring at me aswell as snape. He is an exceptionally skilful wizard whose coldly sarcastic and controlled exterior conceals deep emotions and anguish. I replied shortly, not looking up at her toadlike face. Whats the difference between harry potter and the deathly hallows the book and harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 the movie. She cares deeply about harry and his parents and seems, at least at the beginning of the book, slightly more softhearted than dumbledore. Minerva mcgonagall in harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Sirius black, remus lupin, peter pettigrew and james potter the bullies of snapes youth, with one of them happening to be the man who married the love of his life, lily. As the story reaches a critical stage, time is running out. Minerva mcgonagallseverus snape works archive of our own.
The unwelcome reunion occured when potters old friend remus lupin secured snapes dream. After harry tells everyone that snape murdered dumbledore, professor mcgonagall attacks him in the great hall. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for an. Boasting magical knowledge and abilities second only to dumbledore. Rowling, on fighting the decision to pit harry potter against severus snape in harry potter and the deathly hallows. Collected poems william topaz mcgonagall, william mcgonagall on. In the film adaptation all students witness the duel, unlike the book in which no one seems to have noticed that snape fled from the castle until mcgonagall tells.
Our headmaster is taking a short break, said professor mcgonagall, pointing at the snape shaped. The daughter of albus dumbledore and minerva mcgonagall book 1. The character of severus snape in harry potter and the half. Minerva mcgonagall in harry potter and the sorcerers. After a broken year at hogwarts, with severus snape appointed headmaster. Seeing our hogwarts favourites all band together in such a riveting way really set the tone for the chapter to come. The tay bridge disaster is probably his most famous poem and tells the tale in grand style. Mcgonagall vs snape, valerio dreelrayk buonfantino.
She has always been a strong woman and her loyalty has never waivered. This was the story where our hero had to confront the villains of his past. Give me my pillowsi you see me here before you, formerly maggie smith, but now the once and future minerva mcgonagall. Umbridge vs mcgonagall, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction. As much as i liked the book version better of snape vs. Snape likely perceived harrys presence under the invisibility cloak. He is an exceptionally skilful wizard whose coldly sarcastic and controlled exterior. Readers will know that snape is portrayed as a bully in early books. The film honored the integrity of the book and even lifted dialogue directly from the source material. They both seem to be better than lestrange, that means all the. She also was the older sister of malcolm and robert jr. This skill likewise may be helping him deflect the magic mcgonagall is throwing at him, though it is equally possible that mcgonagall, knowing his ability, is using occlumency, as much as she is able to, to block snapes probes. He was fighting for dear life and when sprout, slughorn and flitwick came, he. Harry potter illustrations, harry potter drawings, harry potter fan art, harry potter books, harry potter universal, harry potter memes, harry potter world, garri potter, severus hermione.
Also, the video the mysterious ticking noise with the chorus snape, snape, severus snape was the winner for best comedy of the year 2007 at youtube. Potions with snape voldemort vs harry how he got his scar no potter here mustaches never fail. Had mcgonagall ever been as classy and mcgonagallish as she was in this chapter. Before long, a frankly awesome duel ensued between mcgonagall, flitwick, sprout and snape, the three fellow professors chipping in to end snapes reign once and for all. A moment of brilliance by snape that i did not realize at first skip to. Say what you want about albus dumbledore and harry potter being the best characters to walk the halls of hogwarts.
Rowling and actress bonnie wright discussed how strong a teacher and character minerva mcgonagall. This is a book that explains how you can help us add amazing drarry fanart to the community. He bullies students to the verge of tears, is blatantly biased towards slytherins, and does not care for an innocent life just because of a childhood grudge. Minerva attended hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry and was sorted into gryffindor house, but it took.
From the way she steadily took down the carrows to the way she confronted snape, it was served ice cold, and gave mcgonagall some muchneeded catharsis without resorting to too much violence. The daughter of albus dumbledore and minerva mcgonagall. Harry potter and the deathly hallows severus snape vs minerva mcgonagall. Professor severus snape was a halfblood wizard who was the son of the witch eileen snape and tobias snape. Minerva attended hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry and was sorted into gryffindor house, but it took the sorting hat five and a half minutes to decide if she was gryffindor or. Mcgonagall woukd win hands down and you know she would if you have ever had the courtesy to read the book. Imagine if you had your own book of spells what would you call it. The daughter of albus dumbledore and minerva mcgonagall book 1 may of pranked the slytherin too much. Fans notice another amazing detail about how professor snape. We dont see mcgonagall transform herself into anything other than human for the remainder of the book, although she does do fun things like turn her desk into a pig. Mcgonagall is shown to have a strong offense in fact it nearly overwhelmed snape in the book. William mcgonagall s parents, charles and margaret, were irish. Part 2 instead of mcgonagall, who fought snape in the book. She may have played the supporting character a lot during the books, but this chapter gave us mcgonagall s crowning moment.
Character profile for minerva mcgonagall from harry potter. Minerva mcgonagall has appeared in the following books. A moment of brilliance by snape that i did not realize at first skip to 19 seconds. And this is not the book, but the movie where we these things have been highlighted. Harry potter and the deathly hallows severus snape vs minerva. Camera pulls back, professor severus snape stands at his desk, newspaper in hand as me, harry and ron stare with dread. As you know, for the majority of the books professor mcgonagall. Part 2 bluray set was released by marie claire uk today, where j. The daughter of dumbledore and mcgonagall book 2 parents lecture. During his lifetime, severus snape was potions master 19811996, defence against the dark arts professor 19961997, and headmaster 19971998 of hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry which he attended as a student from 1971 until 1978. Harry potter story starters monique mcgonagall wattpad.
The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for an open. Severus snape was potions master, defense against the dark arts teacher, and head of slytherin at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry. So i agree that movie snape was, at least to some degree, kinder or with less ill intent. Book snape doesnt, mcgonagall seemed to be beating him, and she has more generally impressive feats of magic. In the film, snape is forced to fight professor mcgonagall after harry. Professor minerva mcgonagall was a scottish halfblood witch, the only daughter of muggle robert mcgonagall and witch isobel ross. I feel like the movie snape was a lot more likable than the book snape by far. At the same time, we know it is in transfiguration that min. An archive of our own, a project of the organization for transformative works. Headmaster severus snape vs professor mcgonagall in hd. Harry, not mcgonagall a new clip from the women of harry potter feature on the harry potter and the deathly hallows. Filch lurks in the doorway, eying them with pleasure.